Finally we did find them on Target's website- after a lot of different searches. We found out that they were called shift key paintings and that they cost $80. A piece. That's right $80 each. That's $340! No Way.
So Brian and I messaged each other at the exact same time with the same solution- Why don't we make them.?
So we did, and the whole project cost us less than $30. Here are the results:
First, we (mostly Brian) painted the backgrounds on all the canvases.We made stencils out of freezer paper. Used a little glue stick to keep them in place on the canvas, and then used pouncers (little round foam craft brushes made for stenciling) and painted in the background color of the stencil.
After the stencil area dried, we painted all the details on, with the freezer paper still in place.
HERE. Just scroll down on the link to see the pictures we chose to make.